Like every other moral and thinking person in North Carolina, I was horrified to read this profile of a local sheriff who was recently the president of our state sheriff's association:
http://www.newsobserver.com/news/immigration/story/1209646.html
The story is wrong on multiple levels, but the thing that stuck out most to me is how this man, who is vested with his community's power, looks at the Latino children in his county. He looks at his county's children, counts them, and sees "trash" and "tax burdens."
And he crystallizes precisely why I consider myself pro-choice. I might not be morally comfortable with abortion but I'm extremely against giving the government control over when and how many children women are allowed to have. Choice isn't just about not having children, it's also about having as many as you want.
He's right -- the Spanish-speaking population, mostly Mexican, in North Carolina is growing fast. I volunteer in my local hospital visiting new parents and most weeks, 7 out of 10 of the mothers and fathers are Spanish-speaking. I walk into hospital rooms overflowing with siblings, cousins and friends -- all brimming with joy.
But many Carolinians, (obviously he wouldn't be in power if he didn't have like-minded constituents) despite professing to be evangelical and pro-life, look at these family's babies and wish they weren't born.
There's a long history in North Carolina of the public's sense of who should and shouldn't have children translating into policy. Between 1929 and 1974, 7,600 people in North Carolina were sterilized -- most of them against their will. Mind you, many states had these programs but after 1945, when the horrors of Nazi Germany were exposed, ended the practice of eugenics. North Carolina continued for another 30 years.
http://againsttheirwill.journalnow.com/
There's also a long tradition of self-proclaimed Christian people de-humanizing other peoples' children. From Quakers who saw Native American kids and thought if they'd just cut their hair and speak English they could stop being "savage" (old-timey speak for what Sheriff Bizell calls "trash") to Catholics and Protestants in Rwanda and Nazi Germany thinking it was acceptable to murder Tutsi and Jewish children.
Anti-choice people talk a good game gushing about Trig, Sarah Palin's Down syndrome baby. But privately you often hear something different.
I remember a couple years ago an anti-choice, evangelical relative around a holiday dinner table said "what a blessing it is" that there are so few babies with Downs being born anymore. Earlier this year, while talking about the ethics of genetic testing, a pro-Sarah Palin friend of mine made a mocking toilet flushing sound, laughed, and said the decision to abort a pregnancy if the baby tested for Downs would be a "no-brainer." If the far-right is comfortable with eliminating children born with Downs, just how far away are we from women being forced to abort pregnancies that turn up genetic abnormalities?
Scratch below the surface of those who profess to want a "culture of life" and too often you find what they mean is white, non-disabled, looks-just-like-me- and - goes - to - my - specific - brand- of- church life.
Sheriff Bizell is the tip of the iceberg (read the comments at the end of the story.)
Joe Biden did a fantastic job yesterday on Meet the Press of explaining how he balances being pro-choice and a practicing Roman Catholic:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/3032608
For those of us on both sides of the choice issue, it's instructive. If you want to cut the rate of abortion, why not create a serious, authentic culture of life where *every* child born in America, not just the perfect and the white and the rich, has the right to education, food, shelter, and health care? If you're really, really serious -- how about quality daycare for women who need to work or finish their education?
Let's look at every child, born in every country, and instead of seeing a "burden" see "The Future."
Monday, September 8, 2008
Saturday, September 6, 2008
The Wrong Walter Reed
My friend Mike had a good write-up of McCain's speech:
http://campaignstops.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/09/05/mccain-missed-the-mark/#comments
I made a comment at the end that the inclusion of the photo of the weird green-tinted Walter Reed Middle School in North Hollywood, Ca. was a significant slip-up. The McCain campaign says, no, they wanted a picture of a school, it was no mistake. Which if true, is funny all by itself since the photo looks a lot more like a Beverly Hills 90210 campus than the school houses of "small towns" like the ones Sarah Palin and I grew up in.
But it seems more likely that they wanted to put him in front of Walter Reed Army Medical Center. While this was obviously an error by a staffer and not the candidate himself, the screw-up still speaks volumes.
I went to the text of McCain's speech and did a word search for "veteran" -- nada. Despite his powerful narrative of being an injured veteran himself, no where in his speech did he talk about other veterans or any plans to improve care for them. No where did he talk the significant number of soldiers returning home with head injuries, amputated limbs and PTSD who are clogging VA and military hospitals that are not equipped to care for them.
Surgeon/writer Atul Gawande had a great chapter in his book "Better: A Surgeons Notes on Performance" about how rapid advancement in battlefield trauma care has outpaced the medical infrastructure at home. Men and women that would have died 20 years ago, are being saved on the battlefield. But they are left with injuries that the VA system as it exists is ill-equipped to help them learn to live with.
There's a similar article on this he wrote for the New England Journal of Medicine:
http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/351/24/2471
" There, after weeks in intensive care and multiple operations, he did survive. This is itself remarkable. Injuries like his were unsurvivable in previous wars. The cost, however, can be high. The airman lost one leg above the knee, the other in a hip disarticulation, his right hand, and part of his face. How he and others like him will be able to live and function remains an open question."
If we truly honor the service of veterans, do we not have an obligation to actually help them cope with their sacrifices when they come home?
President Bush was shamed by the media for the state of Walter Reed Medical Center last year, and John McCain took the opportunity to speak up. However, what has John McCain actually done for VA and military health systems as a top lawmaker on the Senate Armed Services Committee? Here is a very, very partisan write up of the issue, but it includes citations, so you can easily look it up for yourself:
http://www.democrats.org/a/2008/02/walter_reed_ann.php
The salient points:
The VA over the next decade faces tremendous challenges. I might oppose that we went to war, but like everyone else, I want the very, very best for the women and men who serve. McCain is uniquely positioned by virtue of his biography-- even more than Obama -- to speak up about care for veterans. It's disheartening enough that he didn't mention health care for veterans (or health care at all, really) in his speech and downright disgraceful that his staff doesn't even seem to know what Walter Reed actually looks like.
http://campaignstops.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/09/05/mccain-missed-the-mark/#comments
I made a comment at the end that the inclusion of the photo of the weird green-tinted Walter Reed Middle School in North Hollywood, Ca. was a significant slip-up. The McCain campaign says, no, they wanted a picture of a school, it was no mistake. Which if true, is funny all by itself since the photo looks a lot more like a Beverly Hills 90210 campus than the school houses of "small towns" like the ones Sarah Palin and I grew up in.
But it seems more likely that they wanted to put him in front of Walter Reed Army Medical Center. While this was obviously an error by a staffer and not the candidate himself, the screw-up still speaks volumes.
I went to the text of McCain's speech and did a word search for "veteran" -- nada. Despite his powerful narrative of being an injured veteran himself, no where in his speech did he talk about other veterans or any plans to improve care for them. No where did he talk the significant number of soldiers returning home with head injuries, amputated limbs and PTSD who are clogging VA and military hospitals that are not equipped to care for them.
Surgeon/writer Atul Gawande had a great chapter in his book "Better: A Surgeons Notes on Performance" about how rapid advancement in battlefield trauma care has outpaced the medical infrastructure at home. Men and women that would have died 20 years ago, are being saved on the battlefield. But they are left with injuries that the VA system as it exists is ill-equipped to help them learn to live with.
There's a similar article on this he wrote for the New England Journal of Medicine:
http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/351/24/2471
" There, after weeks in intensive care and multiple operations, he did survive. This is itself remarkable. Injuries like his were unsurvivable in previous wars. The cost, however, can be high. The airman lost one leg above the knee, the other in a hip disarticulation, his right hand, and part of his face. How he and others like him will be able to live and function remains an open question."
If we truly honor the service of veterans, do we not have an obligation to actually help them cope with their sacrifices when they come home?
President Bush was shamed by the media for the state of Walter Reed Medical Center last year, and John McCain took the opportunity to speak up. However, what has John McCain actually done for VA and military health systems as a top lawmaker on the Senate Armed Services Committee? Here is a very, very partisan write up of the issue, but it includes citations, so you can easily look it up for yourself:
http://www.democrats.org/a/2008/02/walter_reed_ann.php
The salient points:
- "McCain has repeatedly voted against amendments in the Senate that would have added funding for healthcare services, but eliminated tax cuts for the wealthy. Funding would have covered such important services as improving care at veterans' hospitals, providing mental health services to soldiers with post-traumatic stress disorder and substance abuse problems."
- "McCain voted against the Kerry amendment that would eliminate increased fees and co-payments for veterans in the TRICARE health care program by raising the discretionary spending limit by approximately $10 billion. The provisions would have been fully offset by eliminating creating corporate tax breaks."
- "McCain was one of only 13 Republicans to vote against an amendment that added over $400 million for inpatient and outpatient care for veterans. "
- "McCain missed an important vote this year that supported the funding of the troops in Iraq and guaranteed them adequate medical care upon returning home.
The VA over the next decade faces tremendous challenges. I might oppose that we went to war, but like everyone else, I want the very, very best for the women and men who serve. McCain is uniquely positioned by virtue of his biography-- even more than Obama -- to speak up about care for veterans. It's disheartening enough that he didn't mention health care for veterans (or health care at all, really) in his speech and downright disgraceful that his staff doesn't even seem to know what Walter Reed actually looks like.
Thursday, September 4, 2008
are you for mccain?
So on the cab ride from the St. Louis airport to the hotel tonight, I asked the cabdriver, who had African accent, where he was from. Ethiopia.
I said, "Oh, my brother was in Ethiopia and Kenya last week."
I told him how people kept asking him in hushed, respectful tones: "are you for mccain?"
And he'd say no and then they'd light up and gush about Obama. Country and tribe don't seem to matter, people in Africa are psyched about Obama.
The cab driver then asked me in a hushed tone "are you for mccain?"
and I said no.
And he lit up and said how important it is for change, how the economy is so slow in St. Louis, how hard it is being a cab driver with sky high gas prices. He's in the middle of the citizenship process now and won't be able to vote in November, but told me to tell everyone to "vote Democrat!"
:)
I said, "Oh, my brother was in Ethiopia and Kenya last week."
I told him how people kept asking him in hushed, respectful tones: "are you for mccain?"
And he'd say no and then they'd light up and gush about Obama. Country and tribe don't seem to matter, people in Africa are psyched about Obama.
The cab driver then asked me in a hushed tone "are you for mccain?"
and I said no.
And he lit up and said how important it is for change, how the economy is so slow in St. Louis, how hard it is being a cab driver with sky high gas prices. He's in the middle of the citizenship process now and won't be able to vote in November, but told me to tell everyone to "vote Democrat!"
:)
Belly of the Beast
When I was about 9 years old, and my family would get together with my dad's sisters family a couple times a year. I was always the only girl cousin. And my cousin Josh, one year older than me, would always force us to play "election." Josh would always come in 1st and get to be president. Then the other three boys would be vice president, Sec. of State., Attorney General [I'm not making this s@# up, we were weird little kids]
I would always come in last and Josh would would say, "well, you can be Secretary of Welfare because that's a girl job."
Josh this year, just like me, got to go to his first convention. The EVIL convention. If you want the inside scoop on the SC delegation in Minnesota, go here:
http://columbiaconservative.blogspot.com/
OK my take on tonight:
I would always come in last and Josh would would say, "well, you can be Secretary of Welfare because that's a girl job."
Josh this year, just like me, got to go to his first convention. The EVIL convention. If you want the inside scoop on the SC delegation in Minnesota, go here:
http://columbiaconservative.blogspot.com/
OK my take on tonight:
- Sweet Jesus these people are horrible at dancing. Earth Wind and Fire +Republicans doesn't mix.
- Cindy McCain really appears to be high on something. And I'm not talking about her country.
- It's weird that they just never offered any concrete plans or even a general direction really beyond DRILL BABY DRILL!!!. Mostly just "let them eat cake." J. McCain tried tonight but he looked pained and annoyed even saying the words "paying your mortgage."
- I started this race wanting to remember that McCain's POW experience is not trivial. But the CONSTANT REPETITION trivialized it. The way they framed it, it's like the experience itself qualifies him for the job. By that calculation should the guys in Gitmo start running for 2012?
Wednesday, September 3, 2008
"Just a Community Organizer"
- BEN FRANKLIN!
- Paul Revere
- Sojourner Truth
- Susan B. Anthony
- Gandhi
- Martin Luther King Jr.
- Cesar Chavez
- Wangari Maathi
- Lech Walesa
Who is your favorite "Just a Community Organizer"?
Drill Baby Drill!
Just like it's weird to me that the Dems let the GOP "own" the cost issue in health care, it's weird that the GOP lets us own alternative energy. Seriously? They're seriously chanting "drill baby drill." And getting all hot and bothered by coal and nuclear energy? It sounds dirty. Literally.
Other weirdness:
Other weirdness:
- They mock unions in one speech then brag that Palin's husband is proud member of steel workers.
- They brag about her small town experience but belittle community work.
- The most bizarre thing to me is how they hold her up as having the most "executive experience." By the same calculation -- small town mayor trumps senate experience -- that means she's more qualified than McCain. So why is she on the bottom of the ticket?
- WHY ON EARTH DID THEY HAVE AN INFANT IN THERE!?! Feminism schmeminism, I'm done not being judgey. I was just in that situation last week. They used that poor kid like a prop, subjecting him to intense noise and light that infants hate. He looked drugged. Poor Trig, whoever your mama is.
Tuesday, September 2, 2008
Secrets, Lies, Babies & Lying about Secret Babies
It seems like we've been talking about secrets, lies, babies, and lies about secret babies all summer. A good chunk of the conversation has been: is this a legitimate concern of "the public."
I had the weird opportunity to let Elizabeth Edwards borrow my computer about a month before we found out about John Edwards baby and the even weirder coincidence of running into John at Maggiano's a couple days before his pathetic little TV-admission. So I was hyper-focused on that home-grown scandal.
Before that, I was deliciously curious about the Durham Devilcrats*. Then I was all about the anti-gay Alabama attorney general who was allegedly caught in bed with a man named "Troy." And before that way too much of my brain was consumed with thinking up clever trivia team names that referenced Elliot Spitzer's fantastic fall from grace.
"Brittney who? Paris as in France? " Unless it's Clooney, I'm barely interested in Hollywood. But give me a good political scandal and I'm hooked.
So now, despite my best feminist intentions, I am breathlessly obsessed with Sarah Palin and which babies belong to which mamas.
In a world with just 24 hours, with only so much attention span for so much news, is this a worthwhile obsession? Do I as a constituent really need to know about this stuff?
I say: Yes. Yes, I do.
Because in almost all of these cases, we see that whatever a person is preaching about the hardest is often in reality, their weakest link. I think there is a "buyer beware" nugget of truth in all of these examples. Think carefully about what people choose as their selling point and why. Think carefully about what *your* selling point is and why.
Don't get me wrong, I am a big fan of passion. And most folks in my world and the world at large are passionate about things such as corruption, alleviating poverty, social justice, having a strong family, etc. for the right reasons. But I think when evaluating candidates it is crucial to evaluate why people choose the positions and passions they choose.
When preachers tell the story of Sodom and Gomorrah they almost always omit the creepy incest part about Lott and his daughters. Similarly, when talking about McCain's passion for anti-corruption, the part about the Keating 5 is almost always left out.
And so I wonder about Sarah Palin. For someone so obsessed with corruption and telling the truth, she sure does have lot of seemingly unvetted skeletons. And for a woman who is allegedly excellent at fishing, she sure does have some tall and smelly tales....
*I'm not sure there is a lesson really in the Durham Devilcrats as they weren't actually elected to anything and didn't hold any power. The lesson is: If you don't want to get penned up in a dog cage and beaten, a good strategy is to not answer Craig's List ads for devil worshiping partners.
I had the weird opportunity to let Elizabeth Edwards borrow my computer about a month before we found out about John Edwards baby and the even weirder coincidence of running into John at Maggiano's a couple days before his pathetic little TV-admission. So I was hyper-focused on that home-grown scandal.
Before that, I was deliciously curious about the Durham Devilcrats*. Then I was all about the anti-gay Alabama attorney general who was allegedly caught in bed with a man named "Troy." And before that way too much of my brain was consumed with thinking up clever trivia team names that referenced Elliot Spitzer's fantastic fall from grace.
"Brittney who? Paris as in France? " Unless it's Clooney, I'm barely interested in Hollywood. But give me a good political scandal and I'm hooked.
So now, despite my best feminist intentions, I am breathlessly obsessed with Sarah Palin and which babies belong to which mamas.
In a world with just 24 hours, with only so much attention span for so much news, is this a worthwhile obsession? Do I as a constituent really need to know about this stuff?
I say: Yes. Yes, I do.
Because in almost all of these cases, we see that whatever a person is preaching about the hardest is often in reality, their weakest link. I think there is a "buyer beware" nugget of truth in all of these examples. Think carefully about what people choose as their selling point and why. Think carefully about what *your* selling point is and why.
Don't get me wrong, I am a big fan of passion. And most folks in my world and the world at large are passionate about things such as corruption, alleviating poverty, social justice, having a strong family, etc. for the right reasons. But I think when evaluating candidates it is crucial to evaluate why people choose the positions and passions they choose.
When preachers tell the story of Sodom and Gomorrah they almost always omit the creepy incest part about Lott and his daughters. Similarly, when talking about McCain's passion for anti-corruption, the part about the Keating 5 is almost always left out.
And so I wonder about Sarah Palin. For someone so obsessed with corruption and telling the truth, she sure does have lot of seemingly unvetted skeletons. And for a woman who is allegedly excellent at fishing, she sure does have some tall and smelly tales....
*I'm not sure there is a lesson really in the Durham Devilcrats as they weren't actually elected to anything and didn't hold any power. The lesson is: If you don't want to get penned up in a dog cage and beaten, a good strategy is to not answer Craig's List ads for devil worshiping partners.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)